Home › Directory › New York › Shelter Island
New York

Hotels & Motels in Shelter Island, New York

← Back to New York

1property

Properties in Shelter Island

Hotel/Motel

Sylvan Lodge

6 Sylvan PL, 11965

Own one of these properties?

Open your motel above and use Claim this listing to connect to the exact listing travelers are already finding, instead of starting a new one from scratch.

Weather in Shelter Island right now

Loading the forecast…

Live forecast from the US National Weather Service.

Plan your stay

Visiting Shelter Island

Where to eat, what to see and a little local history, all close to the motels above. Tap any place for directions.

Places from Overture Maps, Wikidata and the National Register of Historic Places. Distances are from the centre of Shelter Island. Check opening times before you go.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many hotels and motels are in Shelter Island, New York?

MotelEasy lists 1 hotel or motel in Shelter Island, New York, including addresses, phone numbers, and amenities.

More Cities in New York

New York (606) Brooklyn (99) Buffalo (74) Albany (64) Lake George (62) Rochester (57) Niagara Falls (55) Jamaica (50) Long Island City (42) Syracuse (39) Bronx (34) Montauk (29) View all of New York →

Own a motel or hotel? Run it on MotelEasy.

Reservations, check-in, housekeeping, staff and OTA sync in one simple dashboard. Flat $20/month after a 14-day free trial.

Start your free trial →

No contracts. Cancel anytime.